The phrase “I think the market is going to” can be an expensive phrase in personal finance. Not because it’s always wrong — sometimes it’s right — but because being right occasionally may not make up for the times it isn’t. The math of market timing is one of those quietly cruel facts of investing: the odds tend to work against you.

Consider what’s actually required to make a successful timing decision. You have to be right about the direction. You have to be right about the magnitude. You have to be right about the duration. And then — the part most people skip — you have to be right about when to go back in. Four correct guesses, in a row, on something that has resisted prediction for a hundred years.

Stepping aside to avoid the worst days can mean missing some of the best ones.

Missing a recovery is one risk of stepping out of the market. Trading costs, taxes and the difficulty of deciding when to return also matter. FINRA’s discussion of market timing explains why the approach requires careful consideration of goals, risk tolerance and implementation costs. No strategy eliminates investment risk.

What this means in practice

For a retired or nearly-retired investor, the temptation is sharpest. The portfolio may be the largest it’s ever been; the consequences feel personal; the news is loud. The reflex is to “do something.” Often, the something that’s right to do is something you already decided to do — in a calmer year, on a different page of the plan.

So I tell clients: the plan is for the loud years. The work we do now is so that when the news is awful, your rule is already written. Two years of essential spending in something steady. A long-term portfolio that you don’t have to touch. A schedule for rebalancing that has nothing to do with how you feel.

When you have a rule, you don’t have to guess. The cost of guessing is what the rule is buying you out of.

— Bruce